ECO-THEOLOGICAL INTEGRATION
IN CHEMISTRY LEARNING: TEACHER STRATEGIES, INSTITUTIONAL SUPPORT, AND STUDENT
TRANSFORMATION IN ISLAMIC EDUCATION
Ririn Eva Hidayati*
*MAN 1 Kota Malang,
Indonesia
*E-mail: ririneva@gmail.com
Abstract
While eco-theology has been widely
discussed in Islamic educational discourse, empirical studies examining its
implementation in chemistry classrooms remain limited. This study investigates
how eco-theological values are integrated into chemistry learning in an Islamic
senior high school and examines the roles of instructional practices, teacher
role modelling, and institutional support in fostering students’ environmental
awareness and responsibility. Using a qualitative case study design, data were
collected through classroom observations, semi-structured interviews with
teachers and eleventh-grade students, and analysis of learning documents at MAN
1 Kota Malang, Indonesia. The findings show that eco-theological values are
systematically embedded in lesson planning, learning activities, and assessment
indicators, particularly in green chemistry and environmental topics. Most
importantly, the integration is reflected in students’
increased environmental awareness, responsibility, and care, as seen in daily practices
such as waste reduction, cleanliness, and resource conservation. Learning is
conducted through contextual discussions, environmental projects, and
reflective dialogues that connect chemical concepts to moral and spiritual
responsibility. Teachers play a crucial role as role models by demonstrating
environmentally responsible behavior and laboratory ethics. Institutional
support through co-curricular programs and green madrasah initiatives
strengthens the consistency of value internalization. The study concludes that
chemistry learning can function not only as scientific instruction but also as
an effective medium for developing eco-theological awareness. This integration
enables chemistry education in madrasahs to contribute to holistic student development,
combining intellectual competence, moral character, and spiritual
responsibility.
Keywords: eco-theology; chemistry
learning; green madrasah; environmental values; character education
Abstrak
Meskipun ekoteologi
telah banyak dibahas dalam wacana pendidikan Islam, studi empiris yang meneliti penerapannya di kelas kimia masih terbatas.
Studi ini menyelidiki bagaimana nilai-nilai
ekoteologi diintegrasikan
ke dalam pembelajaran kimia di sebuah sekolah menengah atas Islam serta meneliti peran praktik pengajaran, teladan guru, dan dukungan institusional dalam menumbuhkan kesadaran dan tanggung jawab lingkungan siswa. Penelitian ini menggunakan desain studi kasus kualitatif dengan teknik
pengumpulan data melalui observasi
kelas, wawancara semi-terstruktur dengan guru dan siswa kelas XI, serta analisis
dokumen pembelajaran di MAN 1 Kota Malang. Hasil penelitian
menunjukkan bahwa nilai-nilai ekoteologi
terintegrasi secara sistematis dalam perencanaan
pembelajaran, aktivitas belajar, dan indikator penilaian, khususnya
pada topik kimia hijau dan lingkungan.
Pembelajaran dilaksanakan melalui diskusi kontekstual, proyek lingkungan, dan dialog reflektif
yang mengaitkan konsep kimia
dengan tanggung jawab moral
dan spiritual. Guru berperan penting sebagai teladan melalui perilaku ramah lingkungan dan penerapan etika di laboratorium. Dukungan institusional melalui
program kokurikuler dan inisiatif
madrasah hijau memperkuat konsistensi
internalisasi nilai-nilai. Dampaknya, siswa menunjukkan peningkatan kesadaran, tanggung jawab, dan kepedulian lingkungan yang tercermin dalam praktik sehari-hari seperti pengurangan sampah, menjaga kebersihan, dan penghematan sumber daya. Penelitian ini menyimpulkan bahwa pembelajaran kimia tidak
hanya berfungsi sebagai pengajaran
ilmiah, tetapi juga sebagai
media yang efektif untuk mengembangkan kesadaran ekoteologis. Integrasi
ini memungkinkan pendidikan kimia
di madrasah berkontribusi pada pengembangan siswa secara holistik yang
mencakup kompetensi intelektual, karakter
moral, dan tanggung jawab
spiritual.
Kata
Kunci: ekoteologi; pembelajaran kimia; madrasah
hijau; nilai-nilai lingkungan; pendidikan karakter
INTRODUCTION
The current worldwide
ecological crisis, in the forms of pollution of the natural environment,
climate change, destruction of biodiversity, and overusing natural resources,
has emerged not only or particularly as a scientific and technical challenge
but has increasingly come to be perceived as a moral and spiritual crisis whose
roots are located in human perceptions and values about nature. All environmental
issues are closely related to anthropocentric perceptions and concepts of the
world that consider humans as the absolute proprietors of nature (Alfiyah, Yuliawati, & Utami,
2024). Furthermore, such perceptions and concepts have led to imbalances in
nature, creating environmental injustices that have raised questions about the
role of education in teaching and promoting a sense of responsibility for
nature and moral and spiritual values (Spash, 2022).
In the field of religious
education, environmental issues, especially in Muslim education, cannot be
separated from a theological framework. This is because, in Islam, the
relationship between humans and the environment is conceptualized through the
idea of amanah, or trust, which does not entail domination or unbridled
use. Through the Qur’anic idea of khalifah fil ’ardh,
humans are conceptualized as the representatives or the vicegerents on the
earth who have been entrusted with the responsibility for the preservation and
proper use of the environment. Thus, environmental destruction will not only be
an unfulfilled ecological responsibility but also a neglect of the spiritual or
moral responsibility to God Almighty. This gives rise to the idea of eco-theology.
This serves to conceptualize and reconcile spiritual or moral values associated
with faith and ecological awareness, in the sense that concern for the
environment must be grounded in such devotion.
Recently, eco-theology
discussion has received extensive attention in Islamic education, especially
within the framework of value-based learning for current environmental issues.
However, most efforts to date on eco-theology and its role in the educational
system have been normative, focusing on issuing theological statements and
moral lessons rather than on the empirical aspects of pedagogical processes.
This resulted in a significant gap between the ideal and actual implementation
of the theology in classroom learning, particularly in the so-called
non-religious subjects.
Science education,
especially chemistry education, has significant potential to address the
aforementioned concern. This is because there is an inherent relationship
between chemistry and issues such as water and air pollution, waste treatment,
chemical reactions in industrial processes, and the use of natural resources (Araripe & Zuin Zeidler, 2024;
Lopez-Fernandez, Cano-Iglesias, &
Franco-Mariscal, 2025). From the perspectives of green chemistry, reaction
rates, buffer solutions, and colloid solutions, science education, specifically
chemistry education, has significant potential to explore the effects of human
actions on the environment (Guerrero & Sjöström, 2025; Jegstad,
2024). In analyzing science education, specifically chemistry education, along
these lines, it is possible to attain scientific knowledge as well as critical
knowledge encompassing sustainability and responsibility towards nature.
Despite its potential,
however, learning chemistry in educational institutions remains largely
cognitive. This learning focus remains on concepts and practices in the lab
rather than on other aspects of learning, such as affectivity, morality, and
spirituality in learning chemistry (Mashami, Ahmadi,
& Pahriah, 2025). Similarly, in madrasahs, it is
clear that moral values are dominated by Islamic Religious studies,
particularly PAI, rather than by Science subjects,
which are regarded as self-contained, valuable disciplines. As a result,
students are not able to achieve holistic learning in chemistry, in which
scientific knowledge is integrated with religious values. Through this,
students can be competent in chemistry but not necessarily ecologically
responsible, as shaped by their religious beliefs.
The madrasah has pursued
institutional efforts to strengthen character education, religious moderation,
and environmental awareness through various policies and programs, especially
those of the Ministry of Religious Affairs. Initiatives such as co-curricular
programs like the Pancasila Student Profile and Rahmatan
Lil Alamin Student Profile Strengthening Project (P5-PPRA), Green Madrasah
Programs, and Contextual project-based learning indicate an increasing
commitment to integrating religious values with current social issues and the
environment. These policies hence provide structural support for embedding
eco-theological values across most subjects, including science education.
MAN 1 Kota Malang itself is
a relevant and strategic case for research on the incorporation of
eco-theological values into chemistry learning. MAN 1 Kota Malang is an Islamic
Senior High School managed by the Ministry of Religious Affairs, with a vision to
instill intellectual superiority, noble traits, and ecological insight in
students simultaneously. Rich contexts are provided by applying green madrasah
programs, project-based learning, and value-driven learning program plans to
examine how eco-theological values can be incorporated into the institutional
vision, including in chemistry education.
Previous studies on
environmental education and integrated values in Islamic schools have focused
either on subject matter in Islamic Religious Education or on the overall
characteristics of character education (Husin, Helmi, Nengsih,
& Rendana, 2025; Mashami
et al., 2025). Concerns about implementing eco-theological values in science
education, particularly in chemistry, remain unclear and underexplored.
Moreover, Previous studies on environmental and sustainability education have
largely examined outcomes such as environmental awareness, pro-environmental
attitudes, scientific literacy, and behavioral change among students (Van de
Wetering et al., 2022; Husin et al., 2025; Mashami et
al., 2025). While these studies provide valuable evidence regarding educational
effectiveness, they offer limited insight into the pedagogical and
institutional processes through which environmental and ethical values are
internalized in classroom practice. Consequently, there remains a need for
research that explores how such values are integrated, enacted, and experienced
within specific educational contexts.
To fill this gap, the
current research explores how chemistry learning processes at MAN 1 Kota Malang
can be used to reinforce and enhance students' eco-theological values.
Specifically, this research explores how eco-theological values are implemented
in lesson design and classroom instruction, reflected in teachers' behavior and
organizational support, and specified within madrasahs in MAN 1 Kota Malang.
Furthermore, the study explores how students perceive, experience, and
internalize eco-theological values and how these values are reflected in their
everyday environmental attitudes and behaviors.
The study's originality
stems from its empirical approach and the application of eco-theological
principles to learning chemistry in the madrasah. Compared with studies on the
application of eco-theological principles to learning chemistry, which are largely
theoretical, this study is important because it explains how learning chemistry
serves as a forum for engaging science and religion in applying eco-theological
principles through role modeling and teamwork in the madrasah. Beyond its
contribution to eco-theological and environmental education research, this
study advances discussions of holistic learning by illustrating how learning
chemistry can simultaneously foster scientific understanding, moral awareness,
spiritual reflection, and environmentally responsible behavior.
It is hoped that the
research will make theoretical contributions to the growth of eco-theology and
value-based science education and have implications for chemistry teachers,
madrasah leaders, and policymakers in the Ministry of Religious Affairs. Although
the research shows that chemistry learning outcomes can contribute to the
development of ecological awareness grounded in religious values, it also
underscores the madrasah's role in cultivating intellectually competent,
spiritually rooted, and ecologically conscious students.
Based on the identified
research gap, this study is guided by the following research questions:
1. How are eco-theological values integrated
into chemistry lesson planning and classroom learning activities in an Islamic
senior high school?
2. How do chemistry teachers promote and
model eco-theological values during the learning process?
3. What forms of institutional support
facilitate the integration of eco-theological values into chemistry learning?
4. How do students perceive and internalize
eco-theological values through chemistry learning, and how are these reflected
in their environmental attitudes and behavior?
These questions provide a
framework for examining the processes, actors, and outcomes involved in
integrating eco-theological values into chemistry education in the madrasah
context.
METHOD
Research Design
This study used a
qualitative descriptive case study design. In this research, a qualitative
approach was conducted to understand how eco-theological values were
integrated, implemented, and internalized through chemistry learning in a
madrasah context. A qualitative case study design was employed because it
enables researchers to investigate a contemporary phenomenon within its
real-life context and develop a holistic understanding of the multiple factors
shaping it (Ebneyamini, Reza, & Moghadam, 2018).
In the present study, the case study approach facilitated an in-depth
examination of pedagogical practices, teacher strategies, institutional
support, and students’ lived experiences related to integrating eco-theological
values into chemistry learning in their natural educational setting.
Research Site and
Participants
The research was conducted
at MAN 1 Kota Malang, an Islamic senior high school managed by the Ministry of
Religious Affairs and actively engaged in character development, environmental
education, and value-based learning initiatives. The school has implemented
various co-curricular environmental programs and the Green Madrasah initiative,
which support the development of students’ environmental awareness and
responsibility. The participants were purposively selected for their direct
involvement in chemistry learning integrated with eco-theological values. The
study involved two chemistry teachers, twelve eleventh-grade students, and one
vice-principal for curriculum affairs. Classroom observations were conducted in
two eleventh-grade science classes across six chemistry learning sessions. The
chemistry teachers were selected because they were directly responsible for
planning and implementing eco-theology-integrated chemistry instruction. At the
same time, the students were chosen to represent different levels of
participation and engagement in classroom learning activities.
Consistent with the case
study design, participants were selected through purposive sampling to include
individuals with direct knowledge and experience of the phenomenon under
investigation (Xu, Wang, & Qian, 2025). The selection focused on information-rich
cases, including chemistry teachers who implemented eco-theology-integrated
instruction, students who participated in learning activities, and school
administrators who supported environmental and value-based education programs.
This strategy enabled the collection of detailed, contextually grounded data on
the processes by which eco-theological values were integrated into chemistry
learning.
Classroom observations were
conducted in two eleventh-grade science classes over six chemistry learning
sessions during the second semester of the 2024/2025 academic year. These
observations focused on instructional practices, teacher-student interactions,
and the integration of eco-theological values into chemistry learning
activities.
Data Sources
Data was collected through
both primary and secondary sources. The primary data were collected through
classroom observation and semi-structured interviews with the chemistry
teachers and students. Secondary data were collected from instructional materials,
including lesson plans, assignments, and learning materials on the value of
eco-theology and environmental studies. The use of the two data approaches
enabled triangulation, making the data credible.
Data Collection Techniques
Non-participatory
observations were conducted in two eleventh-grade chemistry classes over six
learning sessions during the second semester of the 2024/2025 academic year.
The observations focused on how eco-theological values were integrated into
lesson delivery, classroom discussions, laboratory activities, teacher role
modeling, and student participation. Observation data were recorded through
detailed field notes and subsequently triangulated with interview and document
analysis data to enhance the credibility of the findings.
Semi-structured interviews
were conducted with two chemistry teachers and twelve eleventh-grade students
who participated in eco-theology-integrated chemistry learning. Each interview
focused on participants’ experiences, perceptions, and responses to the
integration of eco-theological values in chemistry education. Interviews lasted
approximately 30–60 minutes and were audio-recorded with participants’ consent.
Semi-structured individual interviews were conducted with two chemistry
teachers, twelve eleventh-grade students, and one vice-principal for curriculum
affairs. The interviews explored participants’ experiences, perceptions, and
reflections on integrating eco-theological values into chemistry learning.
Teacher interviews focused on instructional planning, teaching strategies, and
challenges encountered during implementation, whereas student interviews
examined learning experiences, value internalization, and perceived behavioral
changes. Each interview lasted between 30 and 60 minutes and was audio-recorded
and transcribed verbatim for analysis. Semi-structured interviews were selected
because they enabled the researcher to maintain consistency across participants
while allowing sufficient flexibility to explore emerging themes and contextual
insights relevant to the study objectives (Xu et al., 2025).
This involved analyzing the
document to establish the congruence between the value-based instructional
planning and implementation. The learning documents were scrutinized to assess
the integration of eco-theology values into the learning objectives, materials,
activities, and procedures.
The research was conducted
at MAN 1 Kota Malang, an Islamic senior high school under the Ministry of
Religious Affairs that actively promotes environmental awareness and character
education through programs such as P5-PPRA and the Green Madrasah initiative.
The participants were
purposively selected for their direct involvement in eco-theology-integrated
chemistry learning. The participants consisted of two chemistry teachers,
twelve eleventh-grade students from science classes, and one vice-principal for
curriculum affairs. The chemistry teachers were selected because they designed
and implemented chemistry learning activities that integrated eco-theological
values. The students were selected to represent diverse levels of participation
and engagement in chemistry learning activities.
Classroom observations were
conducted in two eleventh-grade science classes over six chemistry learning
sessions during the second semester of the 2024/2025 academic year. These
observations focused on instructional practices, teacher-student interactions,
and the integration of eco-theological values into chemistry learning
activities.
The participants were
purposively selected for their direct involvement in eco-theology-integrated
chemistry learning. To enhance the transparency of the research context and
data collection process, the characteristics of the participants and observation
activities are presented in Table 1.
Table
1.
Characteristics of Participants and Data Collection Activities
|
Participant Group |
Code |
Number |
Role |
|
Chemistry Teachers |
T1–T2 |
2 |
Main informants |
|
Students (Grade XI) |
S1–S12 |
12 |
Student perspectives |
|
Vice Principal |
VP1 |
1 |
Institutional support |
|
Observation Classes |
OC1–OC2 |
2 classes |
Learning observation |
|
Observation Sessions |
OS1–OS6 |
6 sessions |
Classroom observation |
Research Instruments
The primary instrument in
the study was the researcher herself, who served as the planner, researcher,
and analyst. The other research instruments used were the observation guide,
the interview guide, and the document analysis guide. They were developed with
reference to indicators of the importance of eco-theology, which can be linked
to ecological awareness, ecological responsibility, and religious significance.
The trustworthiness of the
research instruments and findings was enhanced through several strategies.
First, the observation guide, interview protocol, and document analysis
checklist were reviewed by experts in chemistry education and qualitative
methodology to ensure content relevance and clarity. Second, methodological
triangulation was employed by combining observations, interviews, and document
analysis. Third, an audit trail consisting of field notes, interview
transcripts, coding records, and analytical memos was maintained throughout the
study. These procedures contributed to the credibility, dependability, and
confirmability of the findings.
Data Analysis
The data analysis employed
an interactive thematic analysis. This involved data reduction, coding,
categorization, and theme formation. The method was applied to data gathered
through observation, interviews, and document analysis to develop themes grounded
in values of eco-theology in learning chemistry. This process ensures
consistency between themes and ideas of eco-theology.
Qualitative data were
analyzed using thematic analysis following the procedures proposed by Braun and
Clarke (2021). The analysis began with data familiarization, during which
interview transcripts, observation notes, and documentary evidence were repeatedly
read to gain an overall understanding of the data. Subsequently, initial codes
were generated inductively by identifying meaningful segments related to the
integration of eco-theological values in chemistry learning.
The initial codes were then
organized into a codebook containing code labels, definitions, inclusion and
exclusion criteria, and representative excerpts from the data. Similar codes
were grouped into broader categories through a process of constant comparison
across data sources. These categories were subsequently reviewed, refined, and
consolidated into overarching themes that captured recurring patterns in the
data. Through this iterative process, five themes were identified:
instructional planning, learning process, teacher role modeling, institutional
support, and student transformation.
To strengthen credibility,
methodological triangulation was employed by comparing findings from
interviews, observations, and document analysis. Consistency across these
sources increased confidence in the interpretation of the findings.
To enhance analytical
transparency, Table 2 illustrates an example of the theme development process
employed in this study. The table demonstrates how raw qualitative data from
interviews, observations, and document analysis were systematically transformed
into initial codes, grouped into broader categories, and ultimately synthesized
into overarching themes. This process provides a clear audit trail showing how
the five themes emerged from the data through iterative analysis and constant
comparison.
Table
2.
Theme Development Process
|
Raw Data Excerpt |
Excerpt |
Category |
Theme |
|
"I integrate environmental stewardship into lesson
objectives." |
Integration of environmental values in lesson planning |
Curriculum Integration |
Instructional Planning |
|
"The teacher connected pollution issues with Islamic
teachings." |
Linking chemistry concepts with religious values |
Classroom Value Integration |
Learning Process |
|
"Our teacher always demonstrates proper waste
management." |
Teacher as environmental role model |
Exemplary Practice |
Teacher Role Modeling |
|
"The Green Madrasah program supports environmental
activities." |
Institutional environmental support |
School Policy and Programs |
Institutional Support |
|
"I now try to reduce plastic use and save water." |
Behavioral change toward environmental responsibility |
Value Internalization |
Student Transformation |
Trustworthiness
Several strategies were
employed to enhance the study's trustworthiness. Credibility was strengthened
through methodological triangulation by comparing evidence obtained from
classroom observations, semi-structured interviews, and document analysis.
Dependability and confirmability were supported by maintaining a comprehensive
audit trail that included field notes, interview transcripts, coding records,
and analytical memos. In addition, the research instruments were reviewed by
experts in chemistry education and qualitative research to ensure their
relevance and clarity. To facilitate transferability, detailed descriptions of
the research context, participants, and learning environment are provided,
enabling readers to assess the applicability of the findings to other
educational settings.
Ethical Considerations
The ethical issues involved
in conducting the research have been addressed. Informed consent has been
sought from the participants. The confidentiality of participants has been
ensured throughout data collection, analysis, and presentation.
RESULTS
& DISCUSSION
This section presents the
results of the research on the influence of learning chemistry on students'
eco-theological values at MAN 1 Kota Malang. This result has been produced
through observation, interviews, and the analysis of relevant documents. The results
are presented in Table 3. This result will be discussed from the perspectives
of eco-theology and values education. The thematic analysis identified five
major themes related to the integration of eco-theological values in chemistry
learning. To provide greater analytical transparency, Table 2 presents each
theme together with representative evidence from multiple data sources and the
corresponding interpretation.
Table
3.
Summary findings from the research conducted
|
Theme |
Empirical Findings |
Interview Evidence |
Observation Evidence |
Document Evidence |
Representative Evidence |
Analytical Interpretation |
|
Instructional planning |
Eco-theological values are explicitly included in the learning
objectives and attitude indicators of chemistry teaching modules. |
Teachers reported integrating eco-theological values into lesson
plans. |
Teachers referred to environmental responsibility during
lessons. |
Teaching modules included environmental stewardship indicators. |
Teaching modules explicitly included learning objectives related
to environmental responsibility and the concept of khalifah fil ardh. Assessment rubrics incorporated indicators of
environmental awareness. |
Eco-theological values were systematically embedded in
curriculum planning, indicating that their integration was intentional rather
than incidental. |
|
Learning process |
The use of contextual learning, environmental projects, and
reflective discussions |
Students described learning connections between chemistry and environmental
ethics. |
Classroom discussions linked pollution issues with Islamic
values. |
Project assignments addressed environmental problem-solving. |
Classroom observations showed students discussing pollution,
waste management, and sustainable chemical practices while linking these
issues to Islamic teachings on environmental stewardship. |
Chemistry learning functioned as a medium through which
scientific knowledge and religious values were interconnected and
contextualized. |
|
Teacher role modeling |
Teachers demonstrate environmentally friendly behavior and
uphold laboratory ethics. |
Students perceived teachers as environmental role models. |
Teachers demonstrated proper waste management practices. |
Laboratory guidelines emphasized environmental responsibility. |
Teachers consistently demonstrated environmentally responsible
behaviors, such as minimizing chemical waste and promoting sustainable
laboratory practices. Students frequently cited teachers as role models. |
The internalization of eco-theological values occurred not only
through instruction but also through social learning and moral
exemplification. |
|
Institutional Support |
Integration of chemistry learning with the co-curricular,
P5-PPRA program and green madrasah initiatives |
School leaders described Green Madrasah initiatives. |
Environmental campaigns were observed on campus. |
School policy documents promoted sustainability programs. |
Green Madrasah programs, P5-PPRA activities, environmental
campaigns, and school policies promoted environmental responsibility across
curricular and co-curricular contexts. |
Institutional support reinforced classroom learning and
contributed to a whole-school approach to eco-theological education. |
|
Impact on students |
Increased environmental awareness, care, and responsibility |
Students reported changes in environmental behavior. |
Students voluntarily participated in environmental activities. |
Reflection assignments documented increased environmental
awareness. |
Students reported increased awareness of environmental issues
and described behavioral changes such as reducing waste, conserving water,
and participating in environmental activities. |
Eco-theological values were transferred from classroom learning to
students’ everyday attitudes and practices, demonstrating meaningful
internalization. |
The convergence of
interview, observation, and document data demonstrates strong triangulation
across data sources. This consistency strengthens the credibility of the
findings. It confirms that the integration of eco-theological values was
reflected not only in participants’ perceptions but also in classroom practices
and institutional documents.
As shown in Table 3, the
integration of eco-theological values occurred through interconnected processes
involving curriculum design, classroom practices, teacher role modeling,
institutional support, and student transformation. The convergence of evidence
across these themes suggests that eco-theological integration in chemistry
learning extends beyond cognitive understanding, contributing to the
development of environmentally responsible attitudes and behaviors.
A. Research Results
1. Integration of Eco-Theological Values
in Chemistry Lesson Planning
The analysis of the
document shows that chemistry educators at MAN 1 Kota Malang integrate
eco-theological values into their learning modules. This is even more apparent
with modules such as green chemistry, reaction rates, buffer solutions, and
colloid solutions. It is possible to detect eco-theological values in lesson
objectives, indicators of attitude, and projects that focus on the environment.
In fact, among the learning
objectives identified in the teaching module mentioned above is for the
students to exhibit responsibility and concern for the environment, hence
reflecting God’s trust in humanity as caliphs over the earth. The identified
objective clearly states the importance of balancing feeling, spirit, and
intellect in the process of gaining knowledge in chemistry.
As confirmed by one
chemistry teacher (T1) who testified to that effect: "As I develop this
module, I include attitude indicators that incorporate concerns for the
environment. I want the students to understand that learning chemistry is not
merely centered on reactions and equations, but much more on the moral
obligation of humanity towards nature, given that nature is God's creation.
"When developing the teaching module, I intentionally integrate
environmental responsibility into the learning objectives and assessment
indicators. I want students to understand that chemistry is not merely about
mastering formulas, reactions, or laboratory procedures. More importantly,
chemistry should help them realize the consequences of human actions on nature.
Therefore, I often connect chemistry topics with the Islamic concept of khalifah
fil ardh, so that students understand that
protecting the environment is not only a scientific obligation but also a
religious responsibility. (Interview with T2, May 12, 2025).
This is reflected in the
evaluation tools, which indeed assess not only cognitive achievement but also
attitudes pertinent to environmental awareness and responsibility. This shows
that eco-theological values are being put into practice rather than being built
up in the teaching process.
2. The Implementation of Eco-theological
Value-Based Chemistry Learning
The observation of learning
revealed the teachers' implementation of the contextual and project approach.
For instance, in the green chemistry subject, learners are expected to evaluate
the environmental impacts of household chemicals and propose improved
alternatives. In one of the learning modules, learners are formed into groups
to study the effects of detergents on water pollution.
The teacher motivates
students to think critically about the environmental impacts of chemical
reactions and human activities. The students are actively involved in class
discussions and projects, in which they are expected to develop environmentally
friendly ideas grounded in their chemical knowledge. Observational evidence
indicates that students are highly engaged when they relate their ideas in
chemistry to environmental issues.
After which, they discuss
what they have discovered and relate it to the importance of human involvement
in caring for the environment through chemical reactions and the concept of
biodegradability. As one student (S1) explained in an interview: “Well, what I
believe is that I have discovered the importance of household chemicals on the
environment. This chemistry class has made me realize I have the urge to learn
and not harm the environment.” – Source: Interviewed Student (S1) in the 11th
Grade on May 15, 2025.
A student reflected on the
learning experience: "Before participating in these learning activities, I
usually viewed chemistry as a subject focused on calculations and scientific
concepts. However, when we discussed pollution, waste management, and green
chemistry, I began to realize that chemistry is closely related to everyday
environmental problems. The discussions helped me understand that our actions,
including the way we use household chemicals, can affect the environment. I
also learned that taking care of nature is part of our responsibility as
Muslims because God has entrusted humans to protect the earth." (S2, May
15, 2025).
Classroom observations
revealed that eco-theological values were explicitly integrated into
discussions on environmental issues. During a lesson on water pollution, the
teacher invited students to analyze the environmental impact of detergent waste
and subsequently linked the discussion to the Islamic concept of khalifah
fil ardh. Observation notes recorded that several
students actively discussed their responsibility to protect water resources and
proposed environmentally friendly alternatives for household chemical use.
(Observation Note, April 24, 2025)
The learning process not
only involves acquiring concepts but also prompts reflection on values and
morals. The teachers typically compare scientific ideas to Islamic terms, such
as mizan (balance), amanah
(responsibility), and wasatiyyah (moderation).
This indicates that what learners are acquiring in their study of chemistry can
be applied to their daily lives and to their moral and spiritual values as
Muslims.
3. Teacher Role Models in Instilling
Eco-theological Values
It has been observed that
chemistry teachers can serve as role models by promoting environmental
responsibility through reducing plastic use in the classroom, reminding
students of the reusability of lab materials, and promoting lab ethics. This
role model can also be seen among the students, and this will be reflected
through quotes such as the following found in the interview: “The chemistry
teacher sometimes reminds us not to waste materials inside the lab and to think
of their effects on nature. Therefore, it is not all theory because we have
instances right before our eyes.” (S3, May 16, 2025).
A similar thought was
voiced by another participant when the participant stated, "In chemistry
class, the teacher not only teaches us, but she also teaches us how to be
responsible, for example, by efficiently using chemicals and not irresponsibly
disposing of waste. This is because the teacher always reminds us to take care
of the environment. After all, it is our religious requirement." (S4, May
16, 2025).
Another student emphasized
the importance of teacher role modeling: "Our chemistry teacher not only
explains environmental issues in class but also demonstrates them through daily
actions. For example, she always reminds us to use chemicals efficiently, avoid
unnecessary waste, and dispose of laboratory materials properly. Because we see
these practices directly, the message becomes more convincing. It makes us
realize that environmental responsibility should be practiced consistently
rather than discussed only in theory." (S5, May 16, 2025).
Observation data also
demonstrated the teacher's role in modeling environmentally responsible
behavior. During laboratory activities, the teacher repeatedly reminded
students to minimize chemical waste, use materials efficiently, and dispose of
chemical residues in accordance with laboratory procedures. These practices
were consistently observed across multiple classroom sessions and served as
practical demonstrations of environmental stewardship. (Observation Note, May
2, 2025).
According to the interview
findings, students have noticed and responded to teachers' behavior. Students
have clearly stated the importance of teachers' consistency with eco-friendly
principles, reinforcing their perception of the need to conserve nature.
Whenever their teachers warned them about the impact of chemical wastes and the
use and misuse of resources, they somehow brought it back to the impact on
their religion, and so on. All these factors have demonstrated the teacher's
effectiveness as a medium for conveying the message of eco-religious education
to students.
4. Collaboration at School for the
Strengthening of Eco-theological Values
Data from school archives
further revealed coordination between the chemistry teachers and the management
of these schools, such as through co-curricular Activities and the Pancasila
Student Profile and Rahmatan Lil Alamin
Student Profile (P5-PPRA) Strengthening Project. For instance, there is a
project titled “Green Madrasah,” which carried out basic environmental Audits
like wastewater management or energy conservation.
The vice-principal for
curriculum affairs explained: "The integration of eco-theological values
is not limited to chemistry lessons. Through the Green Madrasah program and
P5-PPRA projects, we encourage all teachers to connect environmental responsibility
with students' moral and spiritual development. Chemistry teachers play an
important role because many environmental issues can be discussed
scientifically in their classrooms. Therefore, school policies are designed to
support the integration of environmental and religious values across curricular
and co-curricular activities." (VP1, May 18, 2025).
School-level activities may
include campaigns and energy conservation activities that students participate
in. This not only reinforces the lessons that students of chemistry have
learned in class but also enables them to apply eco-theological lessons in
their daily lives. This ensures that the application of eco-theological values
in education does not depend on an individual within the madrasah education
system.
5. Students' Understanding and Attitudes
Toward Eco-Theological Values
The results of the
interview analysis indicate that most students can formulate values related to
ecological theology based on their understanding of the relationship among man,
God, and nature. This is because it is reflected in students' knowledge and
awareness of their moral and spiritual obligations toward nature. Therefore,
they associate the values with positive attitude shifts toward issues such as
minimizing waste, saving water, and being Concerned about cleanliness and the
surroundings.
This understanding has been
described by one student (S6), who said, "I know that there is an
involvement between human beings, God, and nature. Because if we destroy
nature, we will also destroy our responsibility towards God. So, in my life, I do
not throw away too many things and look after cleanliness."
"Learning chemistry
increases my awareness that protecting nature is part of our duty as God's
servants. Since then, I have tried to save water, avoid throwing trash
carelessly, and keep my surroundings clean, because these are ways to show our
good faith to God and other people." (S7, May 18, 2025).
One student described
changes in personal behavior after participating in the learning activities:
"Learning chemistry through environmental issues has changed the way I
think about nature. Previously, I rarely considered the environmental impacts of
my daily activities. Now, I try to reduce plastic use, save water, and be more
careful when disposing of waste. I feel that protecting the environment is not
only beneficial for society but also part of my responsibility before God. This
awareness developed gradually through classroom discussions and school
environmental programs." (S8, May 18, 2025)
B. Discussion
The discussion will be
organized thematically around the findings of this research. Every finding from
this research will be explained in a manner consistent with relevant theories
and other research to demonstrate its significance within the existing literature.
1. Integration of Eco-theology Values in
Chemistry Learning Planning
From the results of this
research, there is evidence of the inclusion of eco-theological values in
learning planning in chemistry education, particularly in learning goals and
attitude descriptors, emphasizing human stewardship of nature as a trust from God.
This implies that learning chemistry is not merely about mastering scientific
knowledge but also about mastering eco-theology awareness.
Document analysis revealed
that eco-theological values were formally embedded in instructional planning.
One teaching module included the following learning objective: "Students
demonstrate environmentally responsible behavior in applying chemical concepts
as part of their role as khalifah fil ardh."
Furthermore, the assessment
rubric included indicators of environmental awareness, sustainable resource
use, and participation in environmental improvement activities. These findings
indicate that eco-theological values were systematically integrated into
curriculum documents rather than being introduced solely during classroom
instruction.
The inclusion of
eco-theology in chemistry lesson plans contributes to the unitary approach to
education in madrasahs. The involvement of the aforementioned value would
ensure that chemistry education is not only cognitive. Consequently, chemistry
education would contribute to the development of students' character and
spirituality.
These findings are also
consistent with eco-theology, as they promote stewardship of the environment as
both an environmental and a social duty. There is evidence that environmental
education is more effective when combined with religion, given its emphasis on
ethical responsibility.
This finding supports the
idea of Buckton et al. (2023), who argue that science education should adopt a
holistic ecological paradigm, viewing humans as part of the web of life rather
than something apart. In an Islamic educational perspective, the concept of khalifah
fil ard views humans as the guardians of the
earth. The use of eco-theological values in planning the chemistry learning
process at MAN 1 Kota Malang indicates awareness of a pedagogical model aligned
with contemporary science's view and Islamic theology regarding science and
nature.
2. Contextual Chemistry Learning as a
Medium for Internalizing Eco-theological Values
The results of the study
show that applying contextual and project-based learning methods can help
learners connect chemistry concepts to environmental issues related to water
pollution and the use of household chemicals. The application of the learning
strategy facilitates the connection between chemical concepts and environmental
issues. The strategy applies to different learning approaches that help
learners understand the various chemical reactions. The strategy allows
learners to connect different ideas to their effects on environmental
sustainability.
In the context of a
madrasah, learning in context is further emphasized and reinforced through
theological reflection. The students will be motivated and encouraged not only
to determine the challenges in their context in terms of scientific knowledge
but also in terms of religion.
These findings seem to
support the theory of meaningful learning, suggesting that knowledge becomes
more significant when it is connected to the learner's real-world experiences.
Moreover, the role of problem-based learning in improving the ability to think
critically, as well as being socially responsible and efficient in achieving
both, is discussed in a study by Sopiansah and Ramafrizal (2025) reported that problem-based learning not
only enhances students’ critical thinking skills but also promotes social
responsibility by engaging learners in authentic problems that require ethical
reflection and collaborative decision-making. Similarly, the
eco-theology-integrated chemistry learning observed in this study encouraged
students to critically evaluate environmental issues while simultaneously
considering their moral and religious responsibilities toward nature. Based on
the current study, part of the social responsibility within this concept is the
development of awareness of the relationships among human beings, the
environment, and God in eco-theology.
3. The Exemplary Role of Chemistry
Teachers in Upholding Eco-Theological Values
Researchers find that,
through the role models of eco-theological values, students adopt
environmentally friendly traits, such as bringing a tote bag to the store,
leaving lights off when not needed, and bringing a tumbler.
The visible involvement of
teacher role models, evident in the study, testifies to the importance of good
examples of conduct instilled through uswah hasanah in Islamic education. They thus exemplify
environmentally responsible behavior both in learning and practical pursuits;
this now reinforces the eco-theological ideals while establishing their
credibility.
This is consistent with a
character education approach that holds that more character values can be
developed through role modeling rather than through talk and telling (Koh,
Askell-Williams, & Barr, 2023; Quiroz-Martinez & Rushton, 2025). Similarly,
Hidayati (2025) argued that role modeling through
teachers' value mediation in environmental education was an important factor in
students' learning. Therefore, role modeling is a critical bridging function of
chemistry teachers at MAN 1 Kota Malang, connecting conceptual eco-theology to
actual engagement with the environment to instill eco-theology in students.
4. Institutional Support and Working with
the School in Developing Eco-Theological Values
The cooperation between
chemistry teachers and school administrators in the co-curricular program
P5-PPRA and green madrasah activity projects demonstrates a commitment to
promoting the development of eco-theological values on non-human,
institutional, and supra-human bases. Thus, sustainability will be ensured in
the implementation of the value of ecology and theology in chemistry education.
School policy documents
further demonstrated institutional support for eco-theological integration. The
Green Madrasah program document explicitly emphasized environmental
stewardship, waste reduction, and sustainability practices as part of character
education. Similarly, the P5-PPRA project guidelines encouraged students to
connect environmental responsibility with religious and ethical values through
project-based activities. (Document Analysis, Green Madrasah Program Guide,
2025).
Institutional support is
also an important aspect, given its immense contributions to ensuring that
factors aligned with eco-theological values in madrasah education continue to
be implemented. This program promotes a whole-school approach that entails alignment
with schools. This is an important aspect, as it ensures consistency in the
implementation of eco-theological values within madrasah institutions.
Based on Koh et al. (2007),
the modification of values and culture within education can continue if it
receives support from the school's educational framework and policies.
Furthermore, the whole-school approach to environmental education emphasizes
involving the entire school to instill ecological awareness among students
(Husin et al., 2025). The result reinforces earlier studies, stating that
values education requires the involvement of the whole school to produce
sustainable outcomes. The school's commitment supports the view that
educational practices are compatible with Islamic values.
5. Effect of Chemistry Learning on
Students' Eco-Theology Understanding and Attitudes
The study has shown not
only students' comprehension of eco-theological values but also changes in
their attitudes toward their everyday activities. This is shown by heightened
concern for cleanliness and for the environment. Learning Transfer Model confirms
that learning is successfully transferred if it is rendered significant and
applicable.
Based on the above
findings, learning chemistry fosters environmentally responsible actions
grounded in religious beliefs. By integrating ideas from both science and
religion, the learning process enhances students' moral consciousness as they
address environmental concerns. Indeed, this finding confirms the effectiveness
of science education in Islamic schools in cultivating students' morals.
According to Okunlola
(2023), knowledge transfer occurs when students use knowledge and values in a
new context (Okunlola, 2023). For this research, knowledge transfer will be
understood as students applying eco-theological values to their attitudes toward
living. This will help confirm the statement by Wetering,
Leijten, Spitzer, & Thomaes
(2022), who argue that good environmental education leads to changes in
thinking and behavior rather than knowledge.
This study has contributed
to the debate on Islamic education by empirically illustrating how eco-theology
has been integrated into chemistry education. While previous studies mainly
focused on and responded to questions of normative discourse, this study has
centered on approaches and mechanisms that ensure value integration.
Indeed, from the above
discussions, it has been verified that there is strategic potential in learning
chemistry at MAN 1 Kota Malang in serving to increase eco-theological values.
By incorporating values into the learning context and through figures, this
research identifies an important role for learning chemistry in fostering
ecological awareness, with an emphasis on religious values.
The findings of this study
have several practical implications for educational leaders and policymakers.
For school principals, the study highlights the importance of fostering an
institutional culture that integrates environmental responsibility with religious
values across curricular and co-curricular activities. School leaders can
strengthen eco-theological learning by providing professional development
opportunities, encouraging interdisciplinary collaboration among teachers, and
supporting school-wide environmental initiatives such as Green Madrasah
programs.
For policymakers, the
findings suggest that environmental education may become more meaningful when
integrated with students’ moral and spiritual frameworks. Educational policies
should therefore encourage contextual and value-based approaches that connect
scientific concepts with ethical and religious dimensions. Such policies may
help schools foster not only environmental knowledge but also environmentally
responsible attitudes and behaviors among students.
Despite its contributions,
this study has several limitations. First, the research was conducted in a
single Islamic senior high school, which may limit the transferability of the
findings to other educational contexts. Second, the study focused primarily on
participants’ experiences and perceptions within a specific learning
environment and did not examine the long-term sustainability of value
internalization among students. Third, the qualitative nature of the study
prioritizes depth of understanding rather than broad generalization.
Future research may address
these limitations by conducting multi-site case studies involving different
types of schools and educational settings. Comparative studies could explore
how eco-theological values are integrated across diverse institutional contexts.
In addition, longitudinal research is needed to investigate whether
eco-theological learning leads to sustained changes in students’ environmental
attitudes, behaviors, and decision-making practices over time. Further studies
may also examine the effectiveness of teacher professional development programs
aimed at integrating eco-theological values into science education.
CONCLUSION
The research findings
indicate that chemistry learning in MAN 1 Kota Malang is a significant element
in developing students' eco-theological values. The integration of
eco-theological value elements into the planning and role-play functions at the
classroom and institutional levels confirms the notion that science education
in madrasahs is not a value-neutral field but can serve as a remarkably
significant medium for the formation of students' character and spirit. The
implication is that chemistry is a field where science and religion meet.
The findings show that
incorporating eco-theological values into chemistry education can be achieved
by integrating environmental values and theological considerations into the
learning experience. The context/study-by-project approach allows the student
to connect their study of chemistry to the needs of the natural world, thereby
prompting questions about the impact of human activity on it through scientific
and theological lenses.
Teachers' role modeling has
also been recognized as playing an important part in the internalization of
eco-theological values. Environmental responsibility, laboratory ethics, and
chemistry teachers are examples that should be incorporated into chemistry
instruction to strengthen the message being conveyed. Role modeling or uswah hasanah has
been recognized as an important part of teaching in a madrasah, where teachers
possess greater moral authority.
Support from the
institution through schemes such as the P5-PPRA and green madrasah projects
promotes the sustainability of integrating eco-theological values. The
whole-school approach would help coordinate every aspect of the school system,
including the curriculum and classroom practices. This makes it easier to live
the value across the various learning contexts. The teachers and administrators
need to collaborate and support the value of education in the madrasahs.
Worth mentioning here is
that, apart from having formulated eco-theological values, the students have
adopted a positive attitude and behavioral change so effectively in their daily
lives that there has been an increase in awareness of cleanliness, waste
management, and environmental preservation. This indicates the positive
transfer of eco-theological values from the classroom to their practical life.
The originality of this
research lies in providing empirical evidence for the potential and
effectiveness of implementing eco-theological notions in chemistry education.
The direct implication of this research is pertinent to chemistry teachers,
madrasah administrators, and Ministry of Religious Affairs officials. This
research can be used to conceptualize and develop a program to model the
chemistry curriculum in a more integrative and holistic manner, addressing
values in education and in theology.
It is also proposed that
future research examine the outcomes and implementation of eco-theological
chemistry learning in terms of students' environmental actions and religious
selves. Moreover, it will be beneficial to examine its outcomes across different
madrasahs. It can also be explored in research that focuses on quantitative
outcomes.
Despite these
contributions, this study has several limitations. As a single-site case study
conducted in one Islamic senior high school, the findings are context-specific.
They may not be directly transferable to other madrasahs with different
institutional cultures, environmental programs, or instructional practices. The
study primarily focused on understanding the processes of eco-theological
integration rather than measuring its long-term impact on students’
environmental behavior. Therefore, caution should be exercised when applying
these findings to broader educational contexts.
REFERENCES
Alfiyah,
A., Yuliawati, S., & Utami, F. (2024). Humans as caliphs on earth:
Environmental responsibility
in Islamic perspective. Journal
Kajian Keislaman, 1(2), 1–6. https://doi.org/10.56566/jks.v1i2.243
Araripe, E., & Zuin
Zeidler, V. G. (2024). Advancing
sustainable chemistry education: Insights from real-world case studies. Current
Research in Green and Sustainable Chemistry, 9,
100436. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crgsc.2024.100436
Braun,
V., & Clarke, V. (2021). Thematic
analysis: A practical guide. SAGE Publications.
Buckton, S. J., Fazey,
I., Sharpe, B., Om, E. S., Doherty,
B., Ball, P., Denby, K.,
Bryant, M., Lait, R., Bridle,
S., Cain, M., Carmen, E.,
Collins, L., Nixon, N., Yap, C., Connolly,
A., Fletcher, B., Frankowska,
A., Gardner, G., ... Sinclair, M. (2023). The regenerative lens: A conceptual framework for regenerative
social-ecological systems. One
Earth, 6(7), 824–842. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oneear.2023.06.006
Ebneyamini, S., Reza, M., & Moghadam,
S. (2018). Toward developing
a framework for conducting case study research. International Journal
of Qualitative Methods, 17(1), 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1177/1609406918817954
Guerrero, G., & Sjöström,
J. (2025). Critical scientific
and environmental literacies: A systematic and critical review.
Studies in Science
Education, 61(1), 41–88. https://doi.org/10.1080/03057267.2024.2344988
Hidayati,
N. A., Waluyo, H. J., Winarni, R., & Suyitno. (2020). Exploring
the implementation of local wisdom-based character education among Indonesian higher education students. International Journal
of Instruction, 13(2),
179–198. https://doi.org/10.29333/iji.2020.13213a
Husin,
A., Helmi, H., Nengsih, Y. K., & Rendana, M.
(2025). Environmental education
in schools: Sustainability and hope. Discover
Sustainability, 6, Article
41. https://doi.org/10.1007/s43621-025-00837-2
Jegstad, K. M. (2024). Inquiry-based
chemistry education: A systematic review. Studies in Science Education, 60(2), 251–313. https://doi.org/10.1080/03057267.2023.2248436
Koh,
G. A., Askell-Williams, H., & Barr,
S. (2023). Sustaining school
improvement initiatives: Advice from educational
leaders. School Effectiveness and School Improvement, 34(3),
298–330. https://doi.org/10.1080/09243453.2023.2190130
López-Fernández, M. D. M., Cano-Iglesias, M. J., & Franco-Mariscal,
A. J. (2025). Chemistry inquiry
conducted by secondary school students into material degradation in the context of sustainability.
RSC Sustainability, 3(3), 3997–4019. https://doi.org/10.1039/d5su00176e
Mashami, R. A., Ahmadi, A., & Pahriah, P. (2025). Green chemistry
and cultural wisdom: A pathway to improving
scientific literacy among high school
students. Social Sciences & Humanities Open,
11, 101653. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2025.101653
Okunlola, J. O. (2023). Learning
transfer in the workplace:
An insight into the missing link
in the education and training of
employees. Studies
in Learning and Teaching, 4(2), 349–354.
Quiroz-Martinez, D., & Rushton, E. A. C. (2025). Teaching
high school chemistry through education for sustainability:
A collaborative case study from Chile. Environmental
Education Research, 1(1),
1–18. https://doi.org/10.1080/13504622.2025.2573145
Spash, C. L. (2022). Conservation in
conflict: Corporations, capitalism and sustainable development. Biological Conservation,
269, 109528. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biocon.2022.109528
Sopiansah, V. A., & Ramafrizal,
Y. (2025). Effectiveness of
implementing problem-based learning to improve
critical thinking skills. Jurnal Pendidikan Ekonomi, 18(1), 1–12. https://doi.org/10.17977/UM014v18i1p001
Van de Wetering, J., Leijten, P., Spitzer, J., & Thomaes, S. (2022). Does environmental
education benefit environmental outcomes in children and adolescents?
A meta-analysis. Journal
of Environmental Psychology, 81, 101782. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2022.101782
Xu, Z., Wang, Y., & Qian, Y.
(2025). The design and application of in-depth interviews in primary care research.
Chinese General Practice
Journal, 2(2), 100062. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cgpj.2025.100062